What Pie Should I Make? A Baking Quiz

What pie should I make? This 12-question personality quiz matches your tastes and kitchen habits with one of six sweet or savory pie suggestions.

What Pie Should I Make

How this quiz works

The What Pie Should I Make quiz has 12 questions about your tastes and kitchen habits. You’ll answer questions about your available time, ingredients and grocery plans. Other questions ask how you follow recipes and what equipment you can comfortably use.

Your result is one of six pie suggestions. It’s a starting point for choosing a recipe, not a check of your pantry. Before cooking, read the recipe’s ingredient list and directions to see if it fits your kitchen.

Choose for the kitchen you have

Start with your time and dietary requirements before choosing a flavor. Check what you already have, then decide how much shopping you’re willing to do. A filling you love won’t help much if you can’t get its ingredients today.

Check the equipment list, too. A recipe might need a rolling pin, mixer or food processor. If you’re new to baking, look for clear steps and a crust you feel comfortable handling. A prepared crust can save some work.

Active time is the time you spend doing the work. Total time also includes waiting, such as baking, cooling or chilling. A no-bake pie can still need hours in the fridge before you can slice it.

If you’re still deciding between dinner and dessert, the quiz about what to eat can help you choose a direction.

What your pie result means

Apple crumble pie

Apple crumble pie pairs an apple filling with a crumb topping instead of a top sheet of pastry. It suits a craving for fruit and a topping with some crunch. You’ll still need to plan for baking and cooling.

Pumpkin pie

A smooth pumpkin filling makes this an option if you prefer a soft texture to chunks of fruit. Check the recipe for eggs and dairy if those affect your choice. Pumpkin alone doesn’t tell you what else is in the filling.

Pecan pie

Pecans give this sweet pie its nutty flavor and texture. If you’re baking for other people, check for nut allergies before choosing it. Read the full recipe before shopping, since the filling needs more than a bag of pecans.

No-bake chocolate pie

Chocolate is the main draw here. Check whether the entire recipe is no-bake, including the crust, and leave enough chilling time. A filling that’s quick to mix may still need a long wait before it holds a slice.

Chicken pot pie

Chicken pot pie is the savory dinner choice among these results. Its filling usually includes chicken, vegetables and sauce under pastry. Check how the recipe handles the chicken, since some call for it already cooked.

Vegan berry pie

A vegan berry pie excludes animal-derived ingredients throughout the filling and crust. That includes butter, eggs and dairy milk. Vegan ingredients don’t have to be organic. Check packaged pastry as well as the filling ingredients before you bake.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Questions of The Quiz

1
How long have you got?
  • Dinner's in about ninety minutes

  • I've got about three hours before dessert

  • My afternoon is free, including time for cooling

  • I can prep briefly and chill it until tomorrow

  • There's no rush, but keep the hands-on work short

  • Tomorrow works if I can bake it tonight

2
Pick something you already have in your kitchen that could go into a pie.
  • Broth

  • Cornstarch

  • Cream

  • Brown sugar

  • Canned milk

  • Oats

3
Your grocery plan?
  • Check the pantry first

  • Buy whatever's on sale

  • Compare frozen and fresh prices

  • Budget for one pricier ingredient

  • Use up yesterday's dinner

  • Grab a few ready-made parts

4
A baking recipe is open on the counter. What usually happens when you follow it?
  • I'd rather cook the filling and buy the pastry

  • I've baked before, and a crooked edge won't bother me

  • I set timers and check the center before stopping

  • Let me start with something I can stir

  • Checking ingredient swaps is already part of my routine

  • Measuring is fine, but shaping dough worries me

5
Your kitchen counter is crowded. What can you comfortably use today?
  • Whisk, bowl, and oven

  • A whisk and fridge space

  • Stovetop pan plus oven

  • Oven, measuring cups, and timer

  • One bowl and a baking dish

  • Peeler and oven

6
I'd finish with...
  • fork marks

  • sugar crystals

  • oat crumbs

  • cookie crumbs

  • cinnamon

  • pastry leaves

7
Pick a requirement for your recipe.
  • Skip nuts in the filling

  • Use only plant ingredients

  • Include meat for dinner

  • Leave eggs out

  • Use a gluten-free crust

  • Make it without dairy

8
Choose your filling.
  • Cold and creamy

  • Soft chunks with a little bite left in them

  • I'd like meat and vegetables in a thick sauce

  • Something juicy and tart enough to make me pause

  • Smooth, gently spiced

  • Sweet with crunch

9
You're missing one ingredient. How do you handle it?
  • Can I buy that part already made?

  • I'll check the back of the cupboard first

  • Something similar is probably in the fruit bowl

  • I've got leftovers that could work instead

  • Let me check a tested swap before changing anything

  • This recipe is worth one quick store trip

10
Your slice is on a plate, with room for something beside it. What would you add?
  • Green salad

  • Whipped cream

  • Black coffee

  • Strawberries

  • Coconut yogurt

  • Vanilla scoop

11
Who gets a slice?
  • Guests at a sit-down meal

  • Family visiting tomorrow

  • Friends with different food needs

  • Whoever needs dinner tonight

  • My roommate after work

  • Anyone wandering into the kitchen

12
Hot take: homemade crust is worth the extra dishes.
  • I'd make it to control what goes in

  • Yes, I actually enjoy rolling it out

  • Sure, if nobody judges the edges

  • Only if the filling takes almost no effort

  • Crushing cookies is enough crust work for me

  • Dinner needs to happen, so I'm buying pastry